This is simple, list a band, and all their albums and rate each one according to how you feel they are.

Paradise Lost:

Lost Paradise - 9/10
Gothic - 10/10
Shades of God - 4/10
Icon - 9/10
Draconian Times - 9/10
One Second - 5/10
Host - 7.5/10
Believe in Nothing - 4/10
Symbol of Life - 8/10
Paradise Lost - 8.5/10
Requiem - 9/10
Faith Divides Us - Death Unites Us - 7.5/10

Anathema:

The Crestfallen - 9.5/10
Serenades - 8.5/10
Pentecost III - 9.5/10
The Silent Enigma - 10/10
Eternity - 9/10
Alternative 4 - 3/10
Judgment - 7.5/10
A Fine Day to Exit - 5.5/10
A Natural Disaster - 2.5/10
Hindsight - 5.5/10
We're Here Because We're Here - 0/10
Falling Deeper - 0/10

Because it's a lame album. I really like the sound of the guitars and Nick's voice (possibly his peak?) but the songs aren't there. Considering what came before and after it should've been better IMO. My rhythm guitarist and I argue about this album all the time. He loves it, whereas I don't, lol. 'Your Hand in Mine' is a good song however.

Cathedral:

Forest of Equilibrium - 8.5/10
Soul Sacrifice - 8.5/10
The Ethereal Mirror - 2.5/10
Static Majik - 7.5/10
Cosmic Requiem - 7.5/10
The Carnival Bizarre - 8.5/10
Hopkins - 0/10
Supernatural Birth Machine - 4.5/10
Caravan Beyond Redemption - 3.5/10
Endtyme - 7.5/10
The VIIth Coming - 8.10
The Garden of Unearthly Delights - 9.5/10
The Guessing Game - 0/10

CATHEDRAL

Forest of Equilibrium - 10/10
Soul Sacrifice - 9.5/10
The Ethereal Mirror - 9/10
Static Majik - 9.5/10
Cosmic Requiem - 8/10
The Carnival Bizarre - 9/10
Hopkins - 8/10
Supernatural Birth Machine - 7/10
Caravan Beyond Redemption - 8/10
Endtyme - 9.5/10
The VIIth Coming - 6/10
The Garden of Unearthly Delights - 9.5/10
The Guessing Game - 7/10

Saint Vitus

Saint Vitus 9.5/10
Hallow's Victim 9/10
Born Too Late 9/10
Mournful Cries 8/10
V 7/10
Children of Doom 7/10
Die Healing 9.5/10

Paradise Lost:

Lost Paradise - 7/10
Gothic - 7/10
Shades of God - 6/10
Icon - 5/10
Draconian Times - 5/10
One Second - 5/10
Host - 4/10
Believe in Nothing - 2/10
Symbol of Life - 4/10
Paradise Lost - 5/10
Requiem - 5/10
Faith Divides Us - Death Unites Us - 4/10

CANDLEMASS

Epicus Doomicus Metallicus - 9/10
Nightfall - 9/10
Ancient Dreams - 7/10
Tales of Creation - 6/10
Chapter VI - 5/10
Dactylis Glomerata - 5/10
From The 13th Sun - 4/10
Candlemass - 6/10
King of Grey Islands - 8.5/10
Death Magic Doom - 8/10

Candlemass:

Epicus Doomicus Metallicus - 2/10
Nightfall - 9/10
Ancient Dreams - 9/10
Tales of Creation - 5/10
Chapter VI - haven't heard it
Dactylis Glomerata - haven't heard it
From The 13th Sun - 3/10
Candlemass - 6/10
King of Grey Islands - 9/10
Death Magic Doom - 8/10

Novembers Doom:

Amid it's Hallowed Mirth - 7/10
For Every Leaf that Falls - 8/10
Of Sculptured Ivy & Stone Flowers - 7.5/10
The Knowing - 10/10
To Welcome the Fade - 9/10
The Pale Haunt Departure - 4.5/10
The Novella Reservoir - 0/10
Into Night's Requiem Infernal - 0/10
Aphotic - 0/10

Cirith Ungol

Frost and Fire-10/10
King of the Dead-10/10
On Foot in Hell-8/10
Paradise Lost-5/10

I'm digging this thread. It's fun to see who rates what.

man...am I the only one who thinks From the 13th Sun should have a ten...

OK, here I go, for a start I'll try rating 3 bands (Only "Full length" albums)...

Skepticism

Stormcrowfleet ---(9/10)
Lead and Aether --(9/10)
Farmakon ---------(8.5/10)
Alloy ---------------(9.5/10)

Shape Of Despair

Shades of... ------------(8.5/10)
Angels of Distress -----(8/10)
Illusion's Play ----------(9/10)

Esoteric

Epistemological Despondency ------------------(9.5/10)
The Pernicious Enigma ---------------------------(9.7/10)
Metamorphogenesis -------------------------------(9.5/10)
Subconscious Dissolution into the Continuum -(9/10)
The Maniacal Vale --------------------------------(9.5/10)
Paragon of Dissonance ---------------------------(9/10)

PS:- My ratings aren't that generous; thing is, these albums are "that" great!

Skepticism:

Stormcrowfleet - 8.5/10
Ethere - 8/10
Lead and Aether - 9/10
AES - 8.5/10
The Process of Farmakon - 7/10
Farmakon - 5/10
Alloy - 9.5/10

My Dying Bride:

Symphonaire Infernus et Spera Empyrium - 10/10
As the Flower Withers - 8/10
The Thrash of Naked Limbs - 8/10
Turn Loose the Swans - 8/10
I Am the Bloody Earth - 7.5/10
The Angel and the Dark River - 7.5/10
Like Gods of the Sun - 4/10
34.788%... Complete - 8.5/10
The Light at the End of the World 8.5/10
The Dreadful Hours - 9.5/10
Songs of Darkness, Words of Light - 10/10
A Line of Deathless Kings - 8/10
For Lies I Sire - 8.5/10
Bring Me Victory - 7.5/10
Evinta - 7.5/10
The Barghest O' Whitby - 10/10

Katatonia:

Jhva Elohim Meth... the Revival - 7.5/10
Dance of December Souls - 6.5/10
Brave Murder Day - 9.5/10
Sounds of Decay - 9.5/10
Saw You Drown - 9/10
Discouraged Ones - 9/10
Tonight's Decision - 6.5/10
Teargas - 8/10
Last Fair Deal Gone Down - 8/10
Tonight's Music - haven't heard
Viva Emptiness - 0/10
The Great Cold Distance - 8/10
Night Is the New Day - 2/10
The Longest Year - haven't heard

Amorphis:

The Karelian Isthmus - 8.5/10
Privilege of Evil - 10/10
Tales from the Thousand Lakes - 2/10
Black Winter Day - 5.5/10
Elegy - 4.5/10
My Kantele - 6.5/10
Tuonela - 8.5/10
Am Universum - 9.5/10
Far from the Sun - 8.5/10
Eclipse - 1/10
Silent Waters - 7/10
Skyforger - 7/10
Magic & Mayhem - Tales from the Early Years - 6/10
The Beginning of Times - 7/10

Pentagram

Relentless-9/10

Day of Reckoning-10/10

Be Forwarned-8/10

Review Your Choices-10/10

Sub Basement-7/10

Show em How-8/10

Last Rites-8/10

ELECTRIC WIZARD

Electric Wizard - 9/10
Come My Fanatics - 9.5/10
Dopethrone - 8.5/10
Lets Us Prey - 8/10
We Live - 8.5/10
Witchcult Today - 8/10
Black Masses - 7/10 *Yeah I know I gave this a 9/10 @ Doommantia but the more I listen, the less I like.

Trouble:

Psalm 9 - 7.5/10
The Skull - 7.5/10
Run to the Light - 8/10
Trouble - 9.5/10
Manic Frustration - 1.5/10
Plastic Green Head - 4.5/10
Simple Mind Condition - 5.5/10
Unplugged - 7.5/10

Solitude Aeturnus:

Into The Depths Of Sorrow - 8/10
Beyond The Crimson Horizon - 8/10
Through The Darkest Hour - 7.5/10
Downfall - 4/10
Adagio - 9.5/10
Alone - 7.5/10

Trouble:

Psalm 9 - 9/10
The Skull - 9.5/10
Run to the Light - 5/10
Trouble - 8.5/10
Manic Frustration - 7/10
Plastic Green Head - 6/10
Simple Mind Condition - 3/10
Unplugged - 5/10

Solitude Aeturnus:

Into The Depths Of Sorrow - 9/10
Beyond The Crimson Horizon - 9/10
Through The Darkest Hour - 9/10
Downfall - 6/10
Adagio - 9/10
Alone - 9.5/10

Evoken:

Shades of Night Descending - 8.5/10
Embrace the Emptiness - 8.5/10
Quietus - 8.5/10
Antithesis of Light - 9/10
A Caress of the Void - 8.5/10

Swallow the Sun:

The Mourning Never Came - 8/10
Ghosts of Loss - 8.5/10
Hope - 9.5/10
Plague of Butterflies - 5/10
New Moon - 6.5/10

HIGH ON FIRE..

The Art of Self Defense - 10/10
Surrounded By Thieves - 9/10
Blessed Black Wings - 10/10
Death is this Communion - 8/10
Snakes for the Divine - 9/10

Trouble:

Psalm 9 - 10/10
The Skull - 9.5/10
Run to the Light - 3/10
Trouble - 9.5/10
Manic Frustration - 9/10
Plastic Green Head - 7.5/10
Simple Mind Condition - 2/10
Unplugged - 7/10

Solitude Aeturnus:

Into The Depths Of Sorrow - 9/10
Beyond The Crimson Horizon - 9/10
Through The Darkest Hour - 9/10
Downfall - 8/10
Adagio - 9/10
Alone - 10/10